The Spanish Guy Standing Next to You Is Not the Reason You’re Struggling

There is something deeply funny—and deeply tragic—about billionaires convincing a man making $52,000 a year that the greatest threat to his freedom is another worker making $14 an hour who happens to speak Spanish.

IMMIGRATIONECONOMICSRIGHTSDEMOCRACYCULTUREPOLITICS

GJ

11/14/20266 min read

Spanish
Spanish

There is something deeply funny—and deeply tragic—about billionaires convincing a man making $52,000 a year that the greatest threat to his freedom is another worker making $14 an hour who happens to speak Spanish.

Think about that for a moment.

The billionaire owns the corporation.

The billionaire owns the media company.

The billionaire has lobbyists in Washington.

The billionaire has accountants finding every possible tax advantage.

The billionaire has enough money to influence elections, policy debates, and public opinion.

And somehow, the worker is told that his economic enemy is the immigrant standing beside him on the factory floor.

Brother.

The immigrant didn't outsource your job.

The immigrant didn't buy your hospital.

The immigrant didn't raise your rent.

The immigrant didn't eliminate your pension.

The immigrant didn't turn a full-time job into a precarious gig.

The immigrant didn't decide that your employer could make record profits while asking you to accept stagnant wages.

The immigrant didn't make healthcare unaffordable.

The immigrant didn't turn housing into an investment vehicle.

The immigrant didn't write the tax code.

And the immigrant certainly didn't become a billionaire while you were working overtime to keep the lights on.

Yet somehow, the political message keeps coming back to the same basic formula:

Look over there.

Look at the immigrant.

Look at the refugee.

Look at the person speaking another language.

Look at the person receiving public assistance.

Look at the worker who supposedly "took your job."

Look anywhere except upward.

Because if working people start looking upward, they might start asking uncomfortable questions.

They might ask why productivity can rise while their share of the economic gains doesn't keep pace.

They might ask why corporate profits can soar while wages remain under pressure.

They might ask why housing costs have become so difficult for ordinary families.

They might ask why healthcare can consume such a large portion of household budgets.

They might ask why retirement security has increasingly become an individual responsibility rather than something workers can reasonably expect from decades of employment.

And, most importantly, they might ask who actually has the power to change any of it.

That is the question the politics of scapegoating tries to prevent.

The Great Misdirection

There is nothing new about convincing one group of struggling people that another group of struggling people is responsible for their problems.

It is one of the oldest political tricks in the book.

Take a genuine economic frustration and attach it to a convenient target.

Then repeat the message often enough that people stop asking whether the target actually caused the problem.

The result is politically useful because anger gets redirected away from institutions and toward individuals.

Instead of asking why wages are inadequate, people are encouraged to blame immigrants.

Instead of asking why housing is unaffordable, they are encouraged to blame immigrants.

Instead of asking why communities have lost good-paying jobs, they are encouraged to blame immigrants.

Instead of asking why corporations can restructure, automate, offshore, consolidate, and cut labor costs while executives and shareholders continue to benefit, they are encouraged to blame immigrants.

The worker is handed an enemy who has almost none of the economic power necessary to be responsible for the conditions he is angry about.

That isn't an accident.

It is misdirection.

The Pickpocket Metaphor

Imagine someone reaching into your pocket and stealing your wallet.

As you realize what happened, another person points dramatically toward a stranger across the street.

"Look! He did it!"

You chase the stranger.

The actual thief walks away with your money.

That is the political trick.

You are being pickpocketed while somebody points dramatically at the guy standing next to you.

And the more furious you become at the person being pointed at, the less likely you are to notice who actually has their hand in your pocket.

Immigrants Are Workers, Too

There is another inconvenient fact buried beneath the rhetoric.

The immigrant working for $14 an hour isn't necessarily some economic outsider living an entirely different life from the American-born worker.

He may be paying rent.

He may be raising children.

He may be working two jobs.

He may be worried about healthcare.

He may be trying to afford groceries.

He may be living paycheck to paycheck.

In other words, he may have considerably more in common with the $52,000-a-year American worker than either has with the billionaire telling them who to blame.

The two workers may have different backgrounds, different languages, and different immigration histories.

But economically, they can occupy remarkably similar positions.

They sell their labor.

Someone else owns the capital.

Someone else makes the major corporate decisions.

Someone else determines how the profits are distributed.

And someone else has vastly more influence over government policy.

That is the class distinction that gets conveniently blurred whenever the conversation becomes obsessed with blaming immigrants.

The Billionaire Doesn't Want You Looking Up

This is where the politics becomes particularly revealing.

A worker angry about his declining economic security has every reason to ask whether the distribution of wealth and power is working in his favor.

But if that worker becomes convinced that another low-wage worker is the problem, the conversation becomes much safer for people at the top.

The billionaire doesn't have to explain his tax bill.

The corporation doesn't have to explain its executive compensation.

The landlord doesn't have to explain the rent.

The hospital system doesn't have to explain the medical bill.

The employer doesn't have to explain the stagnant wage.

The politician doesn't have to explain the policy choices that helped create the environment.

Everyone gets to point somewhere else.

And the worker gets to remain angry.

Just not at the people with the greatest capacity to affect the underlying system.

Divide the Workers, Protect the Powerful

There is an obvious political advantage to keeping working people divided against one another.

A united workforce can demand better wages.

A united electorate can demand stronger labor protections.

A united community can demand affordable housing.

A united public can demand accessible healthcare.

A united population can demand that economic policy serve more than those who already possess enormous wealth.

But if workers are convinced that their fellow workers are the enemy, solidarity becomes much harder.

The warehouse worker blames the immigrant.

The immigrant blames the company.

The rural worker blames the city.

The city worker blames the suburbs.

Older workers blame younger workers.

Younger workers blame older workers.

And everyone is encouraged to fight everyone else while the people with the most economic power continue accumulating more of it.

That is how a system can remain deeply unequal while convincing millions of people that the real problem is the person standing beside them.

Stop Looking Sideways

None of this means every economic problem is caused by billionaires, or that immigration has no economic effects worth debating.

Those are legitimate subjects for serious policy discussion.

Immigration policy can affect labor markets, wages, housing demand, public services, and government finances in different ways depending on the population, location, industry, and time period.

But serious discussion requires evidence.

It requires distinguishing between documented effects and political mythology.

And it requires asking a basic question:

Who actually has the power to make the changes we are demanding?

A $14-an-hour worker does not set corporate compensation.

He does not determine the federal tax code.

He does not decide whether a company closes a factory.

He does not establish hospital prices.

He does not control mortgage rates.

He does not determine zoning policy.

He does not write labor law.

He does not decide how much executives are paid.

He does not determine whether corporations invest in workers or prioritize shareholder returns.

He is a worker.

Just like you.

And perhaps that is the point.

Because the easiest person to blame is often the person who has the least power to defend himself.

Look Up

If you are making $52,000 a year and struggling to afford a home, healthcare, groceries, childcare, or retirement, your frustration is legitimate.

But before you accept the explanation that another working person is responsible for your problems, ask a few questions.

Who owns the company?

Who sets the wages?

Who owns the housing?

Who controls the capital?

Who writes the laws?

Who spends millions lobbying policymakers?

Who benefits most from the current economic arrangement?

Who has the power to change it?

Those questions might lead somewhere more productive than blaming the person standing next to you.

Because the immigrant worker didn't steal your future.

The billionaire didn't necessarily personally cause every hardship you face, either.

But pretending that a $14-an-hour worker is the central threat to the economic freedom of a $52,000-a-year worker is one hell of a convenient story for people who have accumulated vastly more wealth and power than either of them.

So the next time somebody tells you that your economic problems are caused by the worker standing beside you, take a second before you point the finger.

Check your pockets.

Then look up.

AI Generated Image

trumpianinsanity.com © 2023-2026 All Rights Reserved

Trumpian Insanity empowers people with the knowledge and tools to participate in meaningful political discourse and contribute to positive change.

Reframe your inbox

Subscribe to my blog and never miss a story.

We care about your data in our privacy policy.